> The First Row is using the User Inputed Bias Watts
per Tube <
>> The Second Row is using 100% Rated Plate Watts.
<<
>>> The Third Row is using Rated Plate Voltage,
but with No Power Limit! <<<
Load
Per
Tube |
Best
Damp
ing
Factor |
Plate
Loss
Per
Tube |
%
Rated
Watts |
Best
lb1 mA
per
Tube |
Best
Vbias
(Eb1)
volts |
Eb1
check |
Vrms
on
plate |
Pout
watts
per
tube |
Pout
watts
total |
Total
mA
Out
pk-pk |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
..
Usage
JavaScript must not be blocked on
your browser for this to work.
First use the pull down menu above the
"Pre-load" button to
pick a tube
and then click on the
"Pre-load" button to load the tube data
and a suggested load,
or just enter all the tube data and tube loading yourself.
Second, click on the
"Calculate" button.
Clicking on the "Calculate" button fills the table and plots the plot.
What do I do with all of this
information?
When looking at the output power, remember that our ears hear volume
logarithmically. For something to sound twice as loud requires ten
times the power (10dB). A 20% difference in power is 0.8dB. That
amount isn't a change in volume, but if that power difference is
located in one frequency range, it can be a difference in "tone." Keep
an eye on the DF (Damping Factor), for that impacts the "tone"
or sound of bass frequencies and impacts how the speaker
performs at its crossover's impedance peaks and dips.
The calculator outputs three different bias points for a given load
impedance.
The first is where you get to pick the
steady state bias power for each tube.
The second is with all tubes running at 100% of rated power which
can cause the Eb1 bias voltage to exceed the rating for tube.
The third is at 100% of rated plate voltage for the tube. This bias
point can cause the steady state power loss to exceed what is rated
for the tube.
On the bottom left, there is a suggested "
RDH (Radiotron
Designer's Handbook)" Best Load" resistance that will get you close to
the maximum output power for the group of tubes being used. I prefer
to use something 33-50% higher than this in order to deal with 8 ohm
speakers being closer to 6 ohms in real life (i.e. use a 6800 to 7500
ohm transformer instead of the recommended 5000 ohm transformer.) The
RDH best load resistance value will change if you change the number of
tubes in parallel. To see the new number, you'll have to hit "
CALCULATE"
again. The "pre-loaded" values automatically display the RDH best
load, but if the plate dissipation or number of tubes in parallel is
changed, the total load resistance on the bank of tubes will not
automatically update. If the recommended
RDH value is negative,
lower Ib0. You may also need to adjust Ebmin if you don't like
the results.
The
DF (Damping Factor) is primary side damping factor that
assumes that the output transformer is wound with super conducting
(zero ohm) wire on the primary and secondary windings. We can't buy
this part yet. As an approximation, when the primary resistance of the
transformer is 1/4 the effective plate resistance of the tube, you are
at the point of diminishing returns. The effective plate resistance is
the Rplate for one tube
/ the total number of tubes in
parallel
/ any reduction in plate resistance from primary side
feedback.
Reminders:
Eb1 is the steady state DC
bias voltage from anode to cathode.
Ib1 is the DC steady state anode bias current.
Eb1 * Ib1 is your static DC power loss per tube. I recommend
keeping this at least below 85% of the rated tube wattage,
particularly with paralleled tubes. Also allow for plenty of air
flow around the bank of paralleled tubes and insure each tube has
its own Grid-Stop resistor.
Pout/Pbias is your plate efficiency. Single ended tubes are
normally bias in class A. Anything over 30% (0.30) is "par for the
course."
Above is an example plot showing
what the typical results will look like.
- The left sloped portion of the purple "Tube 0V Grid" line shows
the curve fit for plate's V and I. The curve fit for the "Tube 0V
Grid" line must have high accuracy above the Ib1 current, i.e. the
dc bias point, for the equations to work. Don't worry about
fitting data points for the curve down by the Ib0 current, your
curve fit software will help you figure out what Ebmin should be.
The "Tube 0V Grid" curve is the plate voltage and current with
Vgrid = 0V which defines the tube's plate resistance at this grid
voltage.
- After the turquoise colored "Load Line" curve hits the "Tube 0V
Grid" line, Ib1 and Eb1 are then shown then on the purple "Tube 0V
Grid" plot.
- Maximum output power occurs when the current swing from where
the "Load Line" intersects the "Vgrid=0V line distortion point" to
the "Ib1" bias point is equal to the current swing from "Ib1" bias
point to the "Ib0" distortion point. This results in having the
same output swing before distorting whether the current is going
up or down from the DC bias point.
- The "Load Line" should be below the brown "Tube's Power Rating"
at all voltages to avoid stressing the tube.
- The plots are calculated with finite voltage steps that change
depending on the tube and the bias point. This can cause the plots
to not perfectly match the data in the table.
Above is an example of a "Bad Load Line."
General rules for Paralleling Tubes:
Do not "DC couple" both the Plate and Cathode of
paralleled tubes at the same time. It makes it hard for the tubes to
bias up correctly. What will happen is that one super hero tube will
try to draw too much current and one slack-off tube will not draw
enough current. The super hero will wear out quickly and the slacker
will make distortion.
This means that if all of the plates read "zero ohms" to each other
and all of the cathodes read "zero ohms" to each other, the circuit
is not likely to bias up and to operate correctly unless the tubes
are perfectly matched over temperature and aging. So with magically
matched tubes, yes it will work, but magically matched tubes only
exist in the modeling world.
With a normal SET, the recommended way to mitigate this is to tie
all the plates together with a wire and give each cathode its own
bias resistor (and bypass cap).
If using a Parafeed setup there is a different "option", each tube
gets its own "high DCR" Plate Choke (or a CCS). Each plate then gets
its own parafeed cap to the output transformer. That way the
cathodes can be tied together and the output transformer can be
connected to the cathodes.
.
Links
to other sites with relevant tube design discussions
Version 2
The Parallel Tube Script was
written by MilliVolt and was based on my General load line web
page.
The site and script has minor edits by VoltSecond.
Send any questions or comments via emails to VoltSecond through
the Tube Asylum.
Change Log
and Known Issues
There are display issues between
Android phones, Android tablets and Windows desktops with
the placement and overlap of the data. Also, inside a given
hardware platform, there are display differences between the
different browsers. What looks great on a desktop, fails
miserably on phones and tablets. What sort of looks "OK" on
a phone, looked unprofessional on a desktop (and that is
being polite about it.) Refreshing the browser cache will
get you the latest compromise between the different formats.
Landscape
view tends to look better than portrait view on small screens.
Ver
1.0 Initial release
Ver
1.1-1.3 Changed pre-loaded "total load" from a static
2566 ohms to be the RDH recommended load for maximum output
power. Changed last calculated row to be at "max rated
voltage."
Ver
1.3-1.8 Changes to resolve issues between data display on
small Android phones and medium sized Android tablets and on
Windows Desktops.
Ver 1.9
A brute force attempt to fix issues with browsers using old
copies of .css and .js scripts.
Ver 2
Added a plot of the load line..